Friday Foofaraw: It’s Like Looking In A Mirror – Why The Chicago Fire Are The New Bill Wirtz Hawks

I won’t put “trigger warning” at the top of this, but “soccer warning” instead. It’s a summer Friday, so let’s get a little loose and I know a lot of you aren’t the footy fan I am.

After three parades in six seasons, it’s almost easy to forget, even for a lifelong fan like me, just how dark the days were for the Hawks and their fans in the late 90s and basically all of the first decade of this century. It might as well have occurred in a different lifetime, and for a lot of Hawks fans, it did.

But to be reminded, I only need to look at another sports team in town, who are seemingly in the exact same position, except their owner hasn’t pickled his own liver and pretty much entire body and thus probably isn’t a death risk like the Old Man was. It’s the Chicago Fire. You might not have heard of them, even if you’re a soccer fan. They sure haven’t made much of an effort to get you to notice, that’s for sure.

In almost every way that the Hawks were a deficient organization back in those days, the Fire have matched them. They’ve also thrown in a stadium that’s nearly impossible for anyone to get to that doesn’t live in the Western or South suburbs. At least the United Center has always been accessible.

An aloof owner who couldn’t give less of a shit? You betcha! Andrew Hauptman bought the team in 2007, and since he took over the Fire have made the MLS playoffs exactly twice, and one of those was in a play-in game in 2012 so that barely counts. And this is in MLS, where they practically beg you to make the playoffs regularly, if not every year.

What other Wirtz-ian boxes does Hauptman check off? Unavailable? For sure. He lives in Beverly Hills, and certainly isn’t around much. Surly with the fans? You better believe it. The most notoriety the Fire have gotten in two years is when their Director of Communications wrote just about the whiniest, you’re-all-a-bunch-of-ungrateful-morons post on their site. It was PR at its best, let me tell you.

Being overly thrifty with the team? Yeah, got that too. While their rivals have brought in admittedly close to washed up stars or actual US internationals to bolster their roster, the Fire have been on the cheap with their Designated Players, which for those who don’t know are spots on MLS rosters that don’t even count against the salary cap and are specifically designed for teams to bring in bigger talent. How’s that gone for the Fire? Well, one of theirs this year, Shaun Maloney, is leaving not even having completed one season. Because buying Scottish internationals is a foolproof plan. And that’s actually been par for the course for the Fire’s Designated Players, while Fire fans watch Jermaine Jones (this one wasn’t actually their fault, but result was still the same), Michael Bradley, Steven Gerrard, Kaka, Andrea Pirlo, and a host of others go elsewhere. Some of the names? David Accam, Gilberto, Nery Castillo, Sherjill MacDonald, Kennedy Igboananike, Alvaro Fernandez, Frederic Puppo. It’s a virtual murderer’s row, if it was meant to murder your passion for the sport and possibly life.

But it goes deeper than the owner, of course. Incompetent management and development is high on the list too. For years the Fire had former player and local legend Frank Klopas as a manager, whose tactics mainly consisted of punting it up to the striker as quickly as possible. He got one playoff appearance when said striker got really hot (back then it was Chris Rolfe). That was about it. They replaced him with Frank Yallop, who at least had some championship pedigree, having won twice with San Jose. Except the game in this country has obviously passed him by, because when you can discern whatever his tactics are, and it’s a real challenge, it appears to be punt it up to the strikers as quickly as possible while also dressing hilariously bad defenders who are very good at looking each other while yet another opposing striker gleefully gallops into acres of space to slot past an increasingly suicidal keeper Sean Johnson (who I can’t tell is actually good or not, seeing as how he’s going to be coming down with PSD soon). It’s not unlike the Alpo-to-Sutter years.

The Fire haven’t developed any players in their system that fans can cling to. This was a team that did bring through DeMarcus Beasley and Chris Armas back in the day, who both became national team regulars (as well as a couple others). Where LA can boast Zardes and Gonzalez on the national team, KC Besler and Zusi, Seattle Brad Evans and Yedlin (now off to Spurs, yes), and this list could go on, the only young player who even remotely looks exciting in the Fire lineup is Harry Shipp, and he’s misused and not sniffing anywhere near the national team as near as I can figure. And from everything you read, the Fire’s developmental system is criminally underfunded.

Off the field, the Fire are just as big of a mess. Quick, remember the last commercial you saw about them that wasn’t aired during a Fire game? I’ll wait. They have no marketing presence in this city, and thus have become a non-entity. And this is Chicago, perhaps the most multinational city in the country behind New York. Maybe even the most. How can a soccer team in this city be a complete afterthought?

Playing in the boonies doesn’t help. Toyota Park isn’t even really on I-55, and Harlem Ave. is the only way to get there which means you’re going to spend 45 minutes to go two miles whether you like it or not. The stadium itself is nice enough I guess, except it’s far too open which doesn’t lend itself to being very loud or creating that much of an atmosphere even when it’s full, which it almost never is these days. Listen to the cauldron that KC’s, or Portland’s, or Seattle’s stadiums can be because the stands are covered and hold the noise and singing in, and it feels like the Fire missed out on an opportunity. It’s just another day in the park for suburban families, basically.

I know a lot of you who are soccer fans kind of look down upon MLS, and I usually do as well. But I think a part of that is because we simply don’t have a local team that we can all get together and support, or at least one that would be worth it. It’s one thing to follow Liverpool or Arsenal or Munich or Barcelona from afar, but it would be quite another to have one we could go regularly watch live.

One of the things that does attract those of us to the sport is that there is still, or at least the illusion of, a real connection between the supporters and the club. Most clubs around the world give their supporters a voice in their organization. Some even have them vote on decisions, like in Seattle. It’s at least colored like one unit instead of  a business-customer model, even though that’s exactly what it is. Again, maybe we’re all fooling ourselves. What we’re not fooling ourselves about is how the Fire have completely severed that tie. And they’ve made it clear they don’t care.

At least some fans are not going quietly into that good night. Our friends at OTF Soccer have organized a protest for tomorrow’s match. Section 8, the most dedicated supporters in the south end of the stadium, is blacking out their section for those who do go inside tomorrow (though that’s an argument we could have at a later date, whether they should be inside at all). I applaud their efforts to try and take their club back, but remain highly cynical whether it will matter at all.

Hauptman has already seen his investment more than quadruple in worth thanks to MLS’s new TV deal and other factors. And that’s just in eight years. He knows he doesn’t have to do anything, and as long as he doesn’t lose all that much year to year he can cash in whenever he wants for a very handsome profit. Only by turning this club into Chivas East, where simply no one shows up and they’re such an embarrassment to the league that the league is forced into action will something happen. But it feels like there are just enough fans who can’t bear to walk away and parents who just want to entertain their kids to keep the Fire barely afloat enough for Hauptman to do that at his leisure.

I miss it. When the Fire played downtown I went to almost every match. I really treasured having a local club to get behind. I still remember Armas’s golden goal to get them to another Cup final. Man it was cold, and man did I not care. I remember climbing over everyone else in Section 8 and everyone climbing over me to swear at Luis Hernandez as he stood in front of us to take a corner, and his huge smile at the sight. Even if things were to turn around I doubt they could ever leave Bridgeview, and we won’t ever have that “Walk To The Ground” that other supporters get.

It’s just a shame.

  • Bubonic1313

    Thanks for the write up & support! Go Hawks! Go Fire!

  • Vadim

    Wow, can’t believe the shittiness of the Fire and tomorrow’s protest is even getting attention from a Blackhawks blog! Thanks for writing this.

    The Fire actually have had one sustained marketing campaign, but it’s been limited to ads on CTA trains and bus stations, and I don’t think anyone even notices though unless you already know who the Fire are.

    Also Sean Johnson is a beast, he deserves better than this team.

  • Don Walsh

    This blog post is grossly unwarranted. The Fire is a proud organization that is constantly striving to deliver a fan experience to make Chicago proud and trophies to make it prouder. Hauptman has spent tens of millions to build the Club and bring in talented players and he has hired smart staff for soccer and business operations. Most of the rage you see is because an ignorant, entitled few who like to hang out on Twitter is outraged that it’s been a whole three years (gasp) since we went to the playoffs. I encourage anyone here to come to see the Fire experience first hand, you’ll like it.

    • Crash

      Someone works for the Fire.

      • JacobEPeters

        Surprisingly his efforts are actually working against the club. There are great employees of the Fire who have worked to keep the connection to the fans, they are the exception, and pretending they are the norm will only keep the organization from improving to what it needs to be.

    • AirTrafficAJ

      Nothing like calling your fanbase ignorant and entitled as a plan to encourage folks to head on down to catch a match.

  • Crash

    It is a shame. I’m a big fan of the sport too and am as passionate about my European based club as i am about the Hawks. But it would be so great to have a local again. Bridgeview was a shit idea from jump. I’ve heard Wilt explain why it was done, but it never was a good idea. Jst a workable one. But they could still make it work with some damn effort. smh

  • nicolehack

    As a long time Fire fan and Section 8 Chicago board member, I really appreciate you writing this.

  • hiyajohnny

    I’m not a Hauptman fan, but I think he’s only been cheap compared to what’s shelled out by the four or five clubs where the league actually rewrites the rules to funnel more aging superstars—the desirable destinations for players eyeing the US from Europe, Africa, Central or South America. One of which we’re simply not.

    The energized base of urban 20- and 30-somethings who we see in the stands at Timbers, Sounders and NYCFC matches? They’ll never venture to Bridgeview. The soccer gods you mentioned (Pirlo, Lampard, Gerrard, Drogba)? Name one who’d want to play in Bridgeview. It hurts to say, but this club’s problems begin and end out there.

  • Jim

  • DJLalow

    Hey Sam, you writing about Liverpool anywhere, anymore?

  • Keith Hartley

    You mean like this walk to the ground?

    Just imagine the entirety of Section 8 walking down Columbus singing and chanting going to see the fire play at soldier field again lead by captain Cesc Fabregas for the 2023 Supporters shield

    I have a vivid imagination

    • jordyhawk

      I crossed the channel early one morning on the ferry from Dover. A handful of Brits on board drinking cans of lager from 6 packs. When the ferry docked they disembarked then turned right around and reboarded. Then it hit me; duty free grog. Worth getting up for I guess. The singing is great (although the words can put you off sometimes). You can have the rest.

  • Say what again

    Fire? Hell, I remember watching the Sting. I kind of hoped the Fire would do things better. Alas……